Postmortem Playbook for Large-Scale Internet Outages: Lessons from X, Cloudflare and AWS

When multiple clouds and providers fail at once: a postmortem playbook SREs can run without second-guessing

Hook: If your monitoring alerts lit up during the recent multi-provider outage that took down X, Cloudflare, and pockets of AWS in late 2025 and early 2026, you already know the hard truth: when dependency failures cascade across the internet, the first two hours decide whether your postmortem will be forensic or fictional. This playbook turns those chaotic timelines into a repeatable, ops-first postmortem process — what to capture, which metrics to freeze, how to communicate internally and externally, and how to turn learning into measurable prevention.

Why this matters now (2026 context)

The last 18 months accelerated several trends that make rigorous postmortems essential in 2026:

• OpenTelemetry and distributed tracing are now near-universal, so you can and should capture end-to-end traces across providers.
• AI-assisted incident diagnostics are common in runbooks and observability consoles, but they are only as good as the preserved data you feed them.
• Regulatory and contractual pressure increased: more SLAs, more compliance reporting, and higher fines for protracted downtime — especially for fintech, healthcare, and public sector customers.
• Multi-cloud and edge hybrid topologies are standard. That expands blast radius and complicates root cause analysis unless you freeze the right signals early.

Principles of an ops-first postmortem

• Freeze facts, not opinions. Capture raw telemetry, exact timestamps, and operator actions before non-repeatable context is lost.
• Automate collection. Human memory fails under pressure; scripts do not. Have one-button data capture for incidents.
• Be blameless and evidence-driven. Focus on systems and processes rather than people to produce actionable systemic fixes.
• Prioritize impact and verification. Ensure action items are measurable and have verification steps and owners.

Immediate incident checklist (first 0-60 minutes)

When an incident begins, follow a tight, prescriptive checklist. The goal in the first hour is to stabilize, preserve evidence, and set clear communication channels.

1. Stabilize and mitigate
   • Execute known mitigations that have clear rollback paths in runbooks.
   • Prioritize customer-facing fixes over internal optimization in the initial phase.
2. Declare and staff the incident
   • Open an incident channel (incident bridge and chat). Assign Incident Commander, Communications lead, Scribe, and domain leads.
3. Freeze metrics and make immutable captures
   • Take immutable snapshots of dashboards, logs, and trace samples. If your observability provider supports export, export now.
4. Preserve config and routing state
   • Save BGP dumps, routing tables, DNS zone snapshots, WAF rules, CDN configuration, and load balancer state.
5. Start an incident timeline immediately
   • Record every alert, operator action, external provider notice, and public status update with exact UTC timestamps.
6. Activate external communications
   • Publish a holding message on your status page and social channels if customer-facing impact exists. Preserve any provider status pages you reference for later audit.

What SREs must capture — the immutable evidence list

When an incident involves third-party providers, the quality of your evidence determines whether you can produce an accurate RCA and verify vendor claims.

• Timestamps — All timestamps should be recorded and normalized to UTC. Record when alerts fired, when the first user report was received, operator actions, and provider status updates.
• Monitoring snapshots — Export graph images and raw time series for the incident window plus a baseline minute-by-minute for the preceding 2–24 hours.
• Trace samples — Capture representative distributed traces for failed and successful requests. Include root cause candidate spans like DNS resolution, TLS negotiation, TCP connect, and application processing.
• Logs — Collect structured logs from ingress, edge (CDN), API gateway, load balancer, and application layers. Prefer raw log files over UI filters.
• Network state — BGP dumps, netflow/CDR data, TCP retransmission and reset counters, pcap of critical paths if feasible.
• Provider artifacts — Screenshots and exported text of provider status pages, incident IDs, support ticket numbers, and any maintenance window notices.
• Config and deployment state — Git commit hashes, IaC state, feature flags, recent deploy changelogs, and any rollbacks performed during the incident. Keep a postmortem template handy to ensure consistent capture.
• Client-side evidence — Samples of client errors (curl output, error codes, user screenshots) and synthetic monitor logs from multiple geographic points.

Example commands to capture fast evidence

curl -s https://status.aws.amazon.com/ -o aws_status.html
kubectl get configmap app-config -o yaml > app-config-utc-2026-01-17.yaml
promql= 'sum(rate(http_requests_total[5m])) by (status)'
# If your observability API supports export, call it now to pull raw data
curl -s 'https://observability.example/api/export?from=2026-01-17T10:00:00Z&to=2026-01-17T11:00:00Z' -o metrics-window.json

Metrics to freeze and why

Do not assume your dashboards will remain intact. Freeze time series and raw counters for the following key signals:

• Traffic and request rates — global and regional RPS, per-endpoint RPS.
• Error rates — 4xx and 5xx broken down by service and region.
• Latency distribution — P50, P95, P99, and the full histogram if available.
• Infrastructure metrics — CPU, memory, disk I/O, and network throughput on load balancers, proxies, and origin pools.
• Network metrics — TCP retransmits, connection resets, SYN rates, and BGP route flap counts.
• Cache metrics — CDN/edge cache hit ratios, origin shield requests, TLS handshake times at edge. Preserve edge TLS timing and certificate state for root-cause validation; see the edge certificate lessons in recent incidents referenced under edge performance.
• Authentication & identity — SSO and OAuth failures, token validation errors, and rate-limiter hits.
• Dependency health — Third-party API error rates and latency, database connection pools, and queue length statistics.

Timelines: How to build one that matters

A timeline is the backbone of a useful postmortem. Capture facts in chronological order with these fields:

1. UTC timestamp (ISO 8601)
2. Source (alert, user report, provider status, operator)
3. Event description (concrete, with links to artifacts)
4. Impact classification (service degraded, single-region outage, global outage)
5. Action taken and person responsible
6. Evidence links (logs, traces, snapshots)

Example timeline entry:

2026-01-15T14:12:03Z | monitoring | global http 5xx spike begins, P95 latency increases from 120ms to 2.4s | impact: degraded | evidence: metrics-window.json, trace-sample-1.json
2026-01-15T14:15:10Z | user-report | multiple user reports from US east | impact: degraded | evidence: user-screenshots.zip
2026-01-15T14:20:00Z | provider-status | Cloud CDN reports partial edge outage, incident ID CDN-2026-01-15-123 | impact: degraded | evidence: cdn-status.png

Blameless RCA frameworks that work

Choose one consistent methodology and apply it every time. Two operationally useful frameworks:

• Systems mapping and contributing factors — Build a causal chain from symptom to root cause and list contributing factors grouped by people/process/technology. This aligns well with complex, multi-provider incidents.
• Root cause + contributing failure modes — State the primary root cause, then enumerate all contributing failure modes with evidence linking them to the timeline.

Root cause sections in postmortems should answer: what failed, why it failed, how it escaped detection, and what controls would have prevented or lessened impact.

Sample RCA deliverable outline

1. Executive summary: brief customer-facing impact statement, duration, affected regions, and business impact estimate.
2. Severity classification and SLA impact.
3. Timeline of events with evidence links.
4. Root cause analysis: factual statement, method used (traces, logs, BGP dumps), and supporting artifacts.
5. Contributing factors.
6. Corrective actions: short-term mitigations and long-term fixes with owners, due dates, and verification steps.
7. Open questions and follow-up items.

Communicating externally — what to say and when

Customers crave timeliness and truth. The default should be transparent, frequent, and factual updates.

• Initial holding message — Within 15–30 minutes if there is customer impact. Confirm you are investigating and give an estimated next update time.
• Ongoing updates — Provide status updates at predictable intervals (e.g., every 30 or 60 minutes) or when a meaningful change occurs. Include what you know, what you are doing, and expected next steps.
• Post-incident summary — Publish an executive summary within 72 hours with an ETA for the full RCA if it requires deeper analysis.
• Final RCA — Publish the full postmortem on your status page or company blog. Redact sensitive content or anything that could aid attackers, but keep the event narrative and action items public.

Templates and terse language

Use structured templates for status updates. Example holding message:

We are aware of increased errors and slow page loads for customers in US East. Engineers are investigating. We will post an update by 2026-01-17T15:30Z. Impacted services: API and web. Affected customers: global. Incident ticket: INC-2026-01234.

Dealing with third-party provider claims

When vendors report they were the source of failure, your preserved evidence is the only neutral currency. Best practices:

• Cross-check vendor messages with your own telemetry and independent synthetic checks from multiple geographies.
• Request incident IDs and root cause details from the provider and link them to your timeline entries.
• Preserve the entire provider status page and any API responses with timestamps for audit.
• When contracts and SLAs matter, document economic impact and capture log evidence before you accept vendor-root cause narratives.

Action items that reduce future blast radius

Postmortems are worthless unless action items are specific, owner-assigned, and verified. Prioritize these categories:

• Observability — Fill tracing gaps, add synthetic checks in under-monitored regions, ensure log retention covers at least 7x incident windows.
• Resilience engineering — Add circuit breakers, backpressure, and better failover across CDNs and DNS providers.
• Runbooks and automation — Convert manual steps used during the incident to automated playbook actions with safe rollbacks and test coverage. Tie your runbooks to a standardized playbook for consistency.
• Supplier management — Improve provider SLAs, cross-training, and runbook alignment with vendor support teams.
• Testing — Expand chaos experiments to mirror real-world provider failure modes discovered in the incident.

Verification and telemetry-driven closure

Every action item needs a verification plan: how will you prove the risk is mitigated? Examples:

• After adding synthetic monitors in three regions, prove that they detect a simulated regional latency spike within 2 minutes.
• After automating a CDN failover, run an automated failover drill in a non-production slice and validate traffic routing and certificate renewal behavior.

Legal, compliance, and security considerations

When outages intersect with customer data, authentication services, or potential security events, follow these guidelines:

• Notify security and legal teams early if there is any possibility of data exposure.
• Preserve chain-of-custody for logs and network captures if incidents escalate to regulatory or legal review.
• Coordinate external disclosures with legal advice when required by industry regulations.

How AI tools fit into modern incident analysis

By 2026, many teams use AI to summarize timelines, propose root causes, or generate draft postmortems. The key guardrails:

• AI can accelerate synthesis but should never replace raw evidence. Always validate AI suggestions against traces and logs.
• Use AI to generate timelines from structured artifacts and to surface anomalous correlations you might miss manually.
• Log AI queries and outputs as part of the incident artifact bundle for transparency and auditability.

Case study highlights (abstracted lessons from recent multi-provider outage events)

Across incidents in late 2025 and early 2026, several recurring lessons emerged:

• Edge dependency surprise — Multiple teams saw global failures because edge certificates/TLS termination on CDNs degraded; capturing TLS handshake timing and certificate expiry state saved the RCA.
• BGP and DNS timing mismatches — Rapid routing changes combined with DNS TTLs created intermittent reachability; preserving BGP dumps plus TTL-aware synthetic checks highlighted the problem.
• Observability gaps — In several cases, important traces had sampling turned down in high-traffic regions. Ensuring trace sampling minimums during elevated error rates would have prevented blind spots. See our monitoring platform notes for vendor capabilities and sampling guidance at monitoring platforms review.

Turn this playbook into a runbook

Operationalize the steps above into your runbook repository. A practical approach:

1. Create a single incident command script that runs on a hotkey to gather all required artifacts and open the incident document with prefilled fields.
2. Embed quick export buttons into dashboards for one-click snapshotting of the exact time window.
3. Maintain a public-facing postmortem template so customers can anticipate the type of detail you will disclose.

Actionable takeaways

• Build one-button evidence capture that exports metrics, traces, logs, and provider status snapshots for the last 2 hours.
• Freeze these metrics immediately during an incident: RPS, error rates, P95/P99 latency, CPU/memory, TCP resets, BGP updates, and CDN cache hit ratios.
• Start a precise, UTC-normalized timeline within the first 10 minutes; record every operator action with an exact timestamp.
• Publish predictable, factual external communications and follow with a public RCA within 72 hours when feasible.
• Convert every on-call improvisation into an automated runbook step validated by tests and chaos experiments.

Final note and call-to-action

Outages that span multiple providers expose invisible assumptions in architecture, instrumentation, and vendor relationships. In 2026, you can't rely on memory, dashboards that evaporate, or vendor statements alone. Build the muscle of fast, reproducible evidence capture and a disciplined, blameless postmortem cadence.

Ready to make your postmortems actionable? Download our incident evidence checklist and runbook templates, or sign up for a hands-on workshop that helps teams implement one-button capture, synthesis pipelines, and verification tests for postmortem action items.

Related Reading

• Review: Top Monitoring Platforms for Reliability Engineering (2026)
• Hybrid Edge–Regional Hosting Strategies for 2026
• Real-time Collaboration APIs Expand Automation Use Cases — An Integrator Playbook (2026)
• Regulation & Compliance for Specialty Platforms: Data Rules, Proxies, and Local Archives (2026)
• Make Your Own LEGO Accessories: 3D Printing Miniatures and Props Safely at Home
• Make Your Travel Sound Better for Less: Budget Bluetooth Speakers Compared (Including Amazon’s Deal)
• From RCS to CRM: Building a Seamless Messaging Pipeline for Sales Teams
• CES Finds for Restaurants: 8 Gadgets That Actually Improve Service
• Skift Megatrends and Travel Stocks: A Tactical Watchlist for 2026